Brother vs Singer Sewing Machine

We may earn a commission from some links on this page.

Quick Answer: Choose the Brother SM1704 for everyday mending if you want a top drop-in bobbin and 17 built-in stitches. Choose the Singer M1500 if you want preset stitch length and width and mainly sew basic seams and hems. The SM1704 and M1500 make four-step buttonholes. If you sew clothes with rows of buttons, move up to the Brother XM2701 or Singer Fashion Mate 3342 for one-step buttonholes. The XM2701 includes narrow hem and blind stitch feet, while the 3342 lets you adjust stitch length and width.

Brother vs Singer at a Glance

FeatureBrother SM1704Singer M1500
Built-in stitches17 utility and decorative stitches6 built-in stitches
ButtonholeFour-stepFour-step
Stitch selectionDialDial with preset length and width
BobbinTop drop-in with a clear coverFront-loading
Free armYesYes
Included presser feetZigzag, zipper, buttonhole, and button sewingAll-purpose, zipper, and buttonhole
Model with a one-step buttonholeBrother XM2701Singer Fashion Mate 3342

What Decides the Choice

Start with what you sew most. For mending and occasional hems, think about how you want to load the bobbin and whether you want preset stitch dimensions. If you sew shirts or dresses with several buttons, the buttonhole controls will matter more. These four models focus on general sewing. If your priority is straight-stitch quilting, our Juki vs Janome comparison covers how a dedicated quilting machine differs from a general sewing machine.

Brother Overview

The Brother SM1704 has a stitch selector dial, a tension dial, and a reverse lever. Brother lists four feet for everyday sewing, including separate feet for zippers, buttonholes, and sewing on buttons. The SM1704 has a clear-view bobbin cover. The XM2701 keeps the top drop-in bobbin and adds a built-in needle threader, 27 built-in stitches, and a one-step buttonhole. Its stitch selection includes blind hem and quilting stitches, and it comes with feet for narrow hems and blind stitching.

Singer Overview

The Singer M1500 has six built-in stitches and presets their length and width, so you can select a stitch with the dial and start sewing without setting those dimensions. Singer describes it as lightweight enough to take to a sewing class. Its bobbin loads from the front. The Fashion Mate 3342 moves the bobbin to the top, adds a built-in needle threader, and gives you 32 built-in stitches with adjustable length and width. It also makes buttonholes in one step.

Stitches and Buttonholes

The M1500 has six built-in stitches, and the SM1704 has 17. If buttonholes are a regular part of your sewing, look at the XM2701 and 3342. On the 3342, you put the button in the buttonhole foot so the machine can size the opening. Brother describes the XM2701 buttonhole as auto-size.

Bobbin Setup and Free Arm

On the M1500, you load the bobbin from the front. On the SM1704, XM2701, and 3342, it drops in from the top. The SM1704 and M1500 both have a free arm for small tubular pieces, such as a sleeve cuff.

Accessories and Warranty

The SM1704 and M1500 both include zipper and buttonhole feet. The XM2701 comes with six feet, including the narrow hem and blind stitch feet, and the 3342 includes a general-purpose foot, zipper foot, buttonhole foot, and button sewing foot. Brother lists a 25-year limited warranty on both models. Singer describes coverage on both machines as up to 25 years and lists separate coverage periods. If a specific repair matters to you, check its coverage before buying.

Key Differences

  • The SM1704 has 17 built-in stitches. The M1500 has six with preset length and width.
  • The M1500 uses a front-loading bobbin. The other three use top drop-in bobbins.
  • The SM1704 and M1500 use four-step buttonholes. The XM2701 and 3342 use one-step buttonholes.
  • The XM2701 and 3342 both have built-in needle threaders.
  • The XM2701 includes narrow hem and blind stitch feet.
  • The 3342 lets you adjust stitch length and width and has 32 built-in stitches.

Who Should Pick Each

Pick Brother if you want a top drop-in bobbin at either level. The SM1704 covers mending and general sewing. The XM2701 suits garment projects where you expect to use its blind stitch foot, narrow hem foot, or one-step buttonhole.

Pick Singer if you want preset stitch dimensions on the M1500 for straightforward seams, or if you want to adjust length and width on the 3342. If you are also shopping for a heavier-duty machine, see our Janome HD3000 vs HD5000 comparison.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which models make a one-step buttonhole?

The Brother XM2701 and Singer Fashion Mate 3342. The Brother SM1704 and Singer M1500 make four-step buttonholes.

Does the Singer M1500 have a free arm?

Yes. Slide off the storage compartment to expose the free arm for sleeve cuffs, trouser hems, and other tubular pieces.

Which Brother has a built-in needle threader?

The XM2701 has an automatic needle threading system. The SM1704 uses manual needle threading.

Can you adjust stitch length and width on the 3342?

Yes. Singer lists both adjustments on the Fashion Mate 3342, so you can change the distance between stitches and how wide a stitch sews.

Verdict on Brother vs Singer

For repairs and occasional hems, choose the SM1704 for its drop-in bobbin and broader built-in stitch selection, or the M1500 for preset stitch dimensions. For regular garment sewing, choose the XM2701 if you will use the included narrow hem and blind stitch feet. Choose the Fashion Mate 3342 if you want to set stitch length and width yourself. Both of those models make one-step buttonholes.